After Nick unexpectedly sends Danielle L and Whitney home, the women are worried he is going to quit the show. He has a long talk with Chris Harrison, and decides to stay, but cancel the rose ceremony and cocktail party. They all head to the Bahamas, and Vanessa gets the first one-on-one date. She tells Nick that she is falling in love with him, and is disappointed that he does not say it back to her. 

Corinne is angry and disappointed when she doesn't get a one-on-one date and is forced to go on another group date with Kristina and Raven. The three of them join Nick on a boat, and swim with sharks. Raven gets the group date rose, even though Kristina bonds with him on the boat and Corinne thinks that she connected with Nick on another level during their time.

Danielle M. gets the second one-on-one date in Bimini. They spent the day together on the island, but at the end of the date, Nick sends her home. She is heartbroken, but says goodbye to all of the girls and inspires Corinne to make another move on Nick to make sure she isn't going home. Nick stops her when she tries to sleep with him, and she is humiliated and even more nervous.

Rachel goes on the last one-on-one date with Nick, and they talk about her family and hometown dates. Instead of having the rose ceremony, Nick just sends Kristina home.