Pretty Little Liars Round Table: "That Girl is Poison"

at .

Between Jenna's coming out party and Garrett's brief release from jail, tensions were high on "That Girl is Poison." What did you think of the episode?

Join Teresa Lopez, Christina Tran, Nick McHatton and myself as we share our take on the latest Pretty Little Liars via our weekly Round Table discussion...


Where did Lucas get the pills and how did they get into Emily's flask?
Nick: I'm sure A planted the pills in Lucas' film canisters, and the Liars were wondering why Spencer's door was open in the premiere.

Teresa: Totally agree with Nick. I think Lucas is definitely disgruntled, but probably not so maniacal as to drug Emily. He's got some issues, so he might be one of the many people A uses to throw the girls off the trail.

Christina: It’s clear Lucas has seen better days. So, I’m betting those pills definitely belong to him; however, I am also in agreement with my co-roundtablers and believe A is once again messing with the liars.

Leigh: Mona. Lucas is not the same sweet Lucas he used to be. I'm not sure how he got them into Emily's flask, but I do think he's part of the A Team.

Who is April Rose?
Nick: The restaurant the Liars frequent is called Apple Rose Grill, but other than a similarity in name I've got nothing.

Teresa: No idea. Another new character to deepen the mystery. I just hope they can give us a little more information about A, unlike Duncan last season.

Christina: You can add this one to the long list of questions I just don’t know the answer to…

Leigh: Isn't she Kristen Chenoweth's character from Glee? Oh no that was April Rhodes. Although I would totally welcome some KChen on PLL, my guess is April Rose is Garrett's alibi somehow, or another red herring. Don't we have enough of those?

Why do you think Jenna decided to reveal she could see?
Nick: If most of Jenna's cards are on the table then there's less opportunity for blackmail again her. I can't decide if she decided to reveal her sight because of the Liars or because A has something on her.

Teresa: Because it serves her purposes. That's something we've always known about Jenna. She keeps people around, makes vaguely threatening statements, and reveals secrets when she has something to gain. I don't know what that is yet, but hopefully we'll find out soon.

Christina: Maybe A made her do it?

Leigh: Who knows? Jenna is a professional liar like the rest of them. Her agenda is not easy to figure out.

Why do you think Spencer is hysterical in next week's promo?
Nick: Toby's in the next episode, so maybe something happens to him?

Teresa: Maybe she gets sent a part of Ali's body. A finger or a whole hand possibly?

Christina: Her family lets her down once again and she feels alone more than ever.

Leigh: Definitely something Toby related. Spencer is used to the fact that her family is effing crazy.

How cute does Hanna look, even in sweatpants?
Nick: Hanna is always cute, but Emily was absolutely beautiful in her waiter uniform for Jenna's party.

Teresa: I liked Hanna way better with her stripped down, mourning the loss of Caleb garb. She was way more relaxed; although it did suck that Caleb wasn't answering any of her messages.

Christina: Super! Sweatpants are secretly a girl’s best friend.

Leigh: I mean, I wish I looked like that after a breakup. I love that Ashley knew Hanna was certainly not rolling to school in that outfit, and thus she was obviously ditching. Caught!

Do you think Aria was really emasculating Ezra?
Nick: Unintentionally, yes, but she's coming from a place of love, and I can't fault her for that. Ezra's been out of a job for a while now, and she had no idea he got a new one. Aria was just looking out for his well-being.

Teresa: Not really. An extra sandwich is not something to get upset about. It would be different if she was trying to buy him a whole refrigerator of groceries or write him a check. I can see those actions as being a blow to his pride, but what she did was blown out of proportion.

Christina: Absolutely not! It was just turkey sandwiches.

Leigh: Ezra was being hypersensitive. People gotta eat!

That Girl is Poison Review

Editor Rating: 4.0 / 5.0
  • 4.0 / 5.0
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
User Rating:

Rating: 4.1 / 5.0 (77 Votes)
Show Comments
Tags: ,

Pretty Little Liars Season 3 Episode 5 Quotes

Ashley: Do you have plans tomorrow?
Hanna: Uh, yeah. I'm going to listen to every sad song I've ever downloaded on repeat.

Spencer: He's your boyfriend, Aria. He's not a baby squirrel.
Aria: I was just trying to do the right thing.
Spencer: Totally wrong. Look, I've been there, I've done that. Every time you baby squirrel Ezra, you're taking away his nuts.
Aria: You did not just say that.